Our Brokers, Our Family

When you join the Nicol Insurance team, you’re joining the family. We’re proud of our Brokers and take pride in their accomplishments. Customer service and attention to details is a priority in our business, so we encourage you to find your broker or brokers below, learn more about them, and feel free to reach out to them with any questions.

Administration

Tim Nicol

Chief Executive Officer

Our fearless leader and CEO is none other than Tim Nicol. He represents the second generation of the Nicol family to run our company, having…

Adam Barfoot

Chief Financial Officer

Adam is Nicol Insurance’s Chief Financial Officer. He has been with the Owen Sound team since 2012, stating that Nicol Insurance has a “great team…

Michelle Van Essen

Executive Assistant

Michelle van Essen is our Executive Assistant working out of Owen Sound. Michelle has spent 15+ years in Business Development roles, primarily in the Financial,…

Krista Tippin

Receptionist

The first face you see when you enter our Owen Sound office is that of our friendly Receptionist, Krista Tippin. She has spent years refining…

Sue Lambkin

Office Coordinator

One of our most integral and long-standing team members is Sue Lambkin. Sue has been dutifully serving as Office Coordinator in Owen Sound since 2001,…

Megan Jackson

Administrative Support

Megan Jackson is Nicols Insurance administrative assistant. Energized and positive, Megan brings a lot of good vibes to the Nicol Insurance, Owen Sound office.

Brenda Cuming

Administrative Support

Brenda has one of the biggest hearts around and serves as our resident animal expert. When she’s not assisting clients or helping to keep our…

Sue Lendvoy

Administrative Support

illing in for someone who was off, Sue Lendvoy joined Nicol Insurance in 2008. Nearly two decades later, she’s now Account Administrator and hasn’t looked…

Jocelyn Follis

Administrative Support

Having previously owned and operated a small business with her husband, Jocelyn Follis understands the ups and downs that both big and small business owners…

Matt Brown

Commercial Account Executive

Working from the Owen Sound office, Commercial Account Executive Matt Brown has built his business through solid customer referrals. His expertise with larger construction companies,…

Rebecca MacVicar

Commercial Account Executive

Rebecca is an Account Executive at our Owen Sound branch and has been with the team since 2012. Her favourite aspects of her job include…

Jaclyn Searles

Small Business Account Executive

Jaclyn Searles is a key member of the small business team for Nicol Insurance’s Commercial Division. Her focused, yet personal approach provides a refreshing change…

Mike Sarvis

Commercial Account Executive

As a full-time Commercial Account Executive, Dad, Husband and Coach, Mike Sarvis is quite possibly one of the most “on-the-go” members of our team.

Jaclyn Gostick

Small Business Account Executive

As an Account Executive with the Nicol Insurance Commercial Lines team, Jaclyn Gostick enjoys working closely with many Ontario businesses.

Luke McConnell

Commercial Account Executive

Biography coming soon!

Ashley O’Leary

Commercial Account Manager

“Trust” is how Ashley O’Leary, defines a “good policy”. For Ashley, trust works in two ways. The first, occurs when the client is “forthcoming with…

Kelly Arsenault

Small Business Account Manager

Kelly Arsenault is no stranger to the multiple aspects of the insurance industry. Working with the Nicol commercial insurance team, Kelly takes business client requests…

Marlene Bell

Commercial Account Manager

Marlene Bell is a highly knowledgeable Commercial Account Manager, working for Nicol’s Owen Sound office from 2001 to 2013, and rejoining our team in 2021.

Tara Walbourne

Commercial Account Manager

As a Commercial Account Manager working out of the Kincardine office, Tara manages a diverse commercial book of business for Nicol’s Commercial Insurance division.

April McNabb

Small Business Account Manager

Biography coming soon.

Sheena Gennow

Commercial Account Coordinator

Along with a love for all things chocolate, Sheena brings a community-first mentality to our team— so much so that if she won the lottery,…

Owen Sound

Tricia Wright

Personal Lines Manager

Tricia Wright is our Personal Lines Manager working out of Owen Sound, and she’s been with the Nicol Insurance team since 2015. Since that time,…

Lynne Kazarian

Personal Account Executive

Lynne is an Personal Account Executive at our Owen Sound office, where she has worked since 2014. At Nicol Insurance, she enjoys the great group…

Amanda Parisien

Personal Account Manager

Amanda Parisien, who returned to her home town back in 2002, enjoys living in close proximity to Nicol Insurance’s Owen Sound office. She is responsible…

Amy Splawnyk

Personal Account Executive

By listening closely to the needs of her clients, Amy designs and delivers a product that will meet their unique needs. Amy measures her success…

Sarah Zammit

Personal Account Manager

Having recently moved to Owen Sound, Sarah, her fiancé and their fur-baby, Bella, love adventuring and exploring around the Grey Bruce area and beyond.

Krista Garrett

Personal Account Manager

For 16 years, Krista Garrett has enjoyed the interaction with her valued clients. She started her career in insurance as a receptionist supporting and learning…

Diane Bailey

Personal Account Executive

For over three decades Diane Baily has been a key player in the insurance industry, and she’s loved every minute of it. Working out of…

Pam Beech

Personal Account Manager

It’s been a little more than five years that Personal Account Manager Pam Beech has been with the Nicol Insurance’s Port Elgin office team.

Shelley Colley

Personal Account Executive

Starting as a summer student more than three decades ago, Shelley Colley began her career in the insurance business and has never looked back.

Rebecca Simpson

Personal Account Manager

Account Manager Becca Simpson works out of the Nicol Insurance Port Elgin office. Focusing on personal lines insurance, Becca came to Nicol after working 16…

Denyse Faulkner

Personal Account Executive

Denyse is an Account Executive who has been part of the Nicol Insurance team since 2007, working out of our Port Elgin office.

Ginny Banks

Personal Account Manager

A genuine and caring person, Ginny Banks is also an experienced sports coach. Her experience in working with patients, mostly those who sustained injuries primarily…

Krista Holtby

Personal Account Executive

Working out of our Kincardine office, Krista Holtby has been a powerhouse Account Executive on our team since 2006. With over 15 years of experience,…

Ashley Bailie

Personal Account Manager

Ashley Bailie is by nature passionate, as she’s eager to help people and make sure their needs are taken care of. The best part about…

Pamela Davis

Personal Account Executive

Pam is an Account Executive who works out of our Wiarton office. She has been in the industry for over 39 years and has been…

Kristin Jarc

Personal Account Executive

Kristin works out of the Orangeville insurance office and loves the “small town feel” of the many surrounding communities.

Dawn Coram

Personal Account Manager

At Nicol Insurance, we pride ourselves in providing exceptional customer service, which is why we are so fortunate to have Dawn…

Kristin Jarc

Personal Account Executive

Kristin works out of the Orangeville insurance office and loves the “small town feel” of the many surrounding communities.

Keneisha Johnson

Personal Account Executive

Account Manager Keneisha Johnson works out of the Orangeville insurance office and is the main contact for day-to-day policy changes and billing inquires.

Krista Lembo

Personal Account Manager

Personal Account Executive Krista Lembo has a wide scope of experience learned from her previous 20 years in the financial industry.

Ana Mendonca

Personal Account Executive

Ana brings 30+ years of experience to our company, and has worked with us from our Flesherton office for over years.

Jim Washington

Personal Account Executive

Jim knows the Mississauga area and its people inside and out, and has a deep understanding of their insurance needs.

Kyle Washington

Personal Account Manager

Kyle takes great pride in leveraging his insurance knowledge to make the lives of his clients easier, elevating his already phenomenal customer service skills.

Christy Lisk

Personal Account Executive

Christy is a Personal Lines Account Executive working out of our Woodstock office. Her strong belief in hard work and being nice to people makes…

Our Brokers, Our Family

Administration

Commercial Lines

Personal Lines

Owen Sound

Saugeen Shores

Kincardine

Bruce Peninsula

Grey Highlands

Orangeville

Mississauga

Woodstock