Nicol Insurance Orangeville

Proudly serving the Orangeville area. We live and work in the communities that we serve and we love to give back to local organizations and charities. In addition to working with the community, you're sure that your insurance representative is local to you and understands your needs.

Our Insurance Services

Father son with personal insurance

Personal Insurance

Our experienced brokers can help you determine the right kind of coverage you need to protect your unique lifestyle.


Commercial Insurance

Whether you are a contractor or an engineer, a manufacturer or wholesaler, as brokers, we can help you protect what you have built by customizing your policy to protect your unique business needs.


Group Insurance

We recognize the importance of attracting and retaining employees by offering a benefit plan suitable to their needs.

Agricultural Insurance

Agricultural Insurance

We understand the unique needs of local farms, whether you run a large-scale agricultural operation or a small hobby farm.

Our Orangeville Teams

  • All
  • Administration
  • Commercial
  • Personal

Kristin Jarc

Today, after teaching customer service for so many years, she finds her new role challenging and rewarding at the same time, “to practice what I preached for years.” She knows what’s important and that it’s all about relationships. At Nicol, “you can still come in and sit with your broker face-to-face. I feel this is really important to everyone.” Kristin is a firm believer that “human contact” is an essential ingredient of a happy.


Keneisha Johnson

Account Manager Keneisha Johnson works out of the Orangeville insurance office and is the main contact for day-to-day policy changes and billing inquires. Her coworkers are like her second family, and together they work towards providing the best experience possible for Nicol Insurance policy holders.


Krista Lembo

Krista is an enthusiastic member of the Nicol Insurance Orangeville office. She possesses a drive to learn new things and works hard to understand her clients needs. She prefers the personal touch and wants to put a face with each name.

Jen Todd Nicol Insurance

Jen Todd

Jen Todd’s favourite part of her role at Nicol Insurance is building relationships. With her focus on people, Jen builds relationships with the intent “to make your day a little bit better”. She exudes a high degree of empathy and spends a lot of her energy making clients and co-workers feel like a “real person”. An excellent fit to the Nicol Insurance team, Jen understands that what motivates her to assist others makes her feel good about herself. Her energetic motivation benefits clients, as they receive the highest level of service from a caring and knowledgeable broker.


Keira Overbeek

Keira Overbeek enjoys working in her hometown of Orangeville, Ontario. Born and raised there, Keira enjoys her position as Personal Lines Account Manager with Nicol Insurance.

Get In Touch with Us


4 Clara Street,
Orangeville, ON L9W 2H6


Phone: 1 (519) 941-6001
Toll Free: 1 (800) 376-5350
Fax: 1 (519) 376-1658


8:30 am – 5:00 pm


Message Us