Shelley Colley Nicol Insurance

Shelley Colley

Role: Personal Account Executive
Phone: 1 (519) 832-2093 ext. 401


One of our most experienced Account Executives, Shelley Colley has spent over 30 years in the insurance industry, joining our Port Elgin office in 2001. Her wealth of experience and bright, positive attitude make her a delight to work with for both clients and coworkers.

Shelley Colley stays active outside of the office volunteering at Pumpkinfest, participating in local charity run, walk and bike events, or just exploring the world and experiencing nature. Shelley also enjoys socializing with friends and clients, and spending lots of time with her husband Bill and miniature dachshund, Duffy. 

What is an Account Executive?

As an Account Executive, Shelley is here to help you through any claim; providing guidance and advice on how to proceed, while working with you or your insurance company for the best results. Every year, your Account Executive will check in with you to review your policy and provide updates on new available coverages that may be important to you. Every three years, they will also source quotes from insurance providers to make sure you’re receiving the best coverage with the most competitive premium.


Rebecca Simpson Nicol Insurance

Shelley works closely with Account Manager, Becca Simpson. Becca is responsible for personal changes to your policy along with billing inquiries. If you’re adding a new driver to your vehicle, looking to adjust your deductible, or have any questions about your coverage, contact Becca Simpson.