Nicol Insurance Port Elgin

We opened our Port Elgin offices in 1987 and have proudly served the Saugeen Shores community ever since. Working with our Port Elgin team means that you're going to be working with members of your own community who understand your local Grey Bruce problems even better than our competitors!

Our Insurance Services

Father son with personal insurance

Personal Insurance

Our experienced brokers can help you determine the right kind of coverage you need to protect your unique lifestyle.


Commercial Insurance

Whether you are a contractor or an engineer, a manufacturer or wholesaler, as brokers, we can help you protect what you have built by customizing your policy to protect your unique business needs.


Group Insurance

We recognize the importance of attracting and retaining employees by offering a benefit plan suitable to their needs.

Agricultural Insurance

Agricultural Insurance

We understand the unique needs of local farms, whether you run a large-scale agricultural operation or a small hobby farm.

Our Port Elgin Team

  • All
  • Chamber Benefits
  • Commercial
  • Personal
  • Small Business

Diane Bailey

For over three decades Diane Bailey has been a key player in the insurance industry, and she’s loved every minute of it. Working out of the beautiful town of Port Elgin, Diane transferred to Nicol Insurance when Nicol acquired the Carruthers Port Elgin office many moons ago. As a knowledgeable and caring broker, Diane has the background and ability to shop insurance companies, for the best coverage her clients can get. By offering them “more than just one option” clients are assured of complete coverage.


Shelley Colley

Starting as a summer student more than three decades ago, Shelley Colley began her career in the insurance business and has never looked back. She has experienced every facet of the business world, including being an owner/operator of her own business. She describes her role as one that provides both service and advice to existing clients.


Rebecca Simpson

If you need someone to guide you through your personal insurance coverage, you can’t do better than Becca Simpson. She’s been our Personal Lines Account Manager in Port Elgin since 2017, and she knows how to navigate personal policies like the back of her hand. You can find her in our Port Elgin office, and she’s always ready to offer a smile and practical advice.


Denyse Faulkner

For over fifteen years Denyse Faulkner has enjoyed being part of the Nicol Insurance personal lines team. Starting out as the front desk receptionist, she has worn many hats and is now settled in her role as a Personal Account Executive. Keeping current is an important role for Denyse, as educating her clients on changes to coverages, and keeping them well protected in the event of a change, is her first priority.


Melissa Western

Bio Coming Soon

Get In Touch with Us


560 Goderich Street,
Port Elgin, ON N0H 2C4


Phone: 1 (519) 832-2093
Toll Free: 1 (800) 376-5350
Fax: 1 (519) 376-1658


9:00 am – 4:00 pm


Message Us