Our Brokers, Our Family

When you join the Nicol Insurance team, you’re joining the family. We’re proud of our Brokers and take pride in their accomplishments. Customer service and attention to details is a priority in our business, so we encourage you to find your broker or brokers below, learn more about them, and feel free to reach out to them with any questions.

Administration

Tim Nicol

Chief Executive Officer

His knowledge of the insurance business has being learned at many levels, experiencing first-hand the diverse and complex insurance world. Not only did he grow…

Adam Barfoot

Chief Financial Officer

Soon after a successful start in accounting, Nicol Insurance Chief Financial Officer Adam Barfoot made the decision that he wanted something more. With the designation…

Michelle van Essen

Executive Assistant

With over two decades in business development, Michelle van Essen enjoys her diverse role as Executive Assistant to Nicol Insurance’s leadership team. Working out of…

Krista Tippin

Receptionist

Growing up in an insurance family, Krista Tippin started working in the financial sector immediately. Quite often the first person clients meet upon arrival at…

Sue Lambkin

Controller

Born and raised in Owen Sound, Sue Lambkin has been with Nicol Insurance since 2001. As Controller, Sue does all the accounting and payroll services…

Megan Jackson

Administrative Support

Megan Jackson is Nicol Insurance administrative assistant. Energized and positive, Megan brings a lot of good vibes to the Nicol Insurance, Owen Sound office. Graduating…

Brenda Cuming

Administrative Support

Account Administrator Brenda Cuming has been working in the insurance industry for close to two decades. A dedicated and hard worker, Brenda prides herself on…

Sue Lendvoy

Retired

Filling in for someone who was off, Sue Lendvoy joined Nicol Insurance in 2008. Nearly two decades later, she’s now Account Administrator and hasn’t looked…

Dawn Coram

Administrative Support

Administrative Support Dawn Coram has been working at Nicol Insurance Orangeville office for half a decade.

Alicia Lawrence

Administrative Support

With a background in banking and data entry, Alicia Lawrence joined the team at Nicol Insurance and brought her dedication to administrative support. She is…

Matt Brown

Commercial Account Executive

Working from the Owen Sound office, Commercial Account Executive Matt Brown has built his business through solid customer referrals. His expertise with larger construction companies,…

Rebecca MacVicar

Commercial Account Executive

Commercial Account Executive Rebecca MacVicar enjoys meeting clients face-to-face. Specializing in Nicol Insurances exclusive program for the Automotive Industry, Rebecca not only liaisons with car…

Jaclyn Searles

Small Business Account Executive

Jaclyn Searles is a key member of the small business team for Nicol Insurance’s Commercial Division. Her focused, yet personal approach provides a refreshing change…

Mike Sarvis

Commercial Account Executive

Mike Sarvis is a life long learner who jumped into the insurance business following a 16 year commercial retail management career. Familiar with most industries,…

Jaclyn Gostick

Small Business Account Executive

As an Account Executive with the Nicol Insurance Commercial Lines team, Jaclyn Gostick enjoys working closely with many Ontario businesses. Working in the Nicol Insurance…

Luke McConnell

Commercial Account Executive

Luke, who has an honours bachelor of arts degree from the University of Windsor as well as a Teachers College Degree, finds the favourite part…

Ashley O’Leary

Commercial Lines Manager

“Trust” is how Ashley O’Leary, defines a “good policy”. For Ashley, trust works in two ways. The first, occurs when the client is “forthcoming with…

Kelly Arsenault

Commercial Account Manager

Kelly Arsenault is no stranger to the multiple aspects of the insurance industry. Working with the Nicol commercial insurance team, Kelly takes business client requests…

Marlene Bell

Commercial Account Manager

Experienced, knowledgable and physically active Commercial Account Manager Marlene Bell absolutely loves the insurance business. Her life long insurance career started right after graduating from…

Jocelyn Follis

Commercial Account Manager

Originally from Meaford, Jocelyn Follis has lived in Owen Sound since 2004. She is comforted by the fact that Owen Sound, in her opinion, “is…

Tara Walbourne

Commercial Account Manager

As a Commercial Account Manager Tara manages a diverse commercial book of business for Nicol’s Commercial Insurance division. She has had many roles throughout her career.…

April McNabb

Small Business Account Manager

Commercial Account Manager, April McNabb enjoys building relationships with both clients and coworkers. Working out of Nicol Insurance’s Port Elgin office, she spends her day…

Sheena Gennow

Small Business Account Manager

Commercial Account Coordinator Sheena Gennow is a key member of the Nicol Insurance commercial accounts executive’s team. As a Nicol Insurance coordinations expert, Sheena keeps…

Dolly Singh

Commercial Administrator

Dolly Singh is an experienced Commercial Lines Administrator with a strong background in the insurance industry that spans over half a decade. Before joining Nicol…

Christine Haslam

Commercial Account Coordinator

Christine Haslam is currently serving as the Commercial Account Coordinator at Nicol Insurance. Christine brings a wealth of experience and a genuine passion for customer…

Owen Sound

Tricia Wright

Personal Lines Manager

Tricia Wright works with the entire Nicol personal lines insurance team. Hired as a support person for the personal lines team, Tricia rose quickly and…

Amy Splawnyk

Personal Account Executive

Amy Splawnyk has fully embraced the insurance world. As personal account executive, Amy brings her strength in organization and determination to the personal line market.…

Sarah Zammit

Personal Account Manager

A friendly people person, Sarah Zammit has customer service in her blood. She has embraced her time working at Nicol Insurance and is the perfect…

Krista Garrett

Personal Account Manager

Helping others is a daily pleasure, and making a difference for her clients, is what she loves most about her role at Nicol Insurance. The…

Jenna Linley

Personal Account Executive

Personal lines account executive Jenna Linley puts her clients “particular needs” first, especially when they come looking for insurance options. For well over a decade,…

Scott McGregor

Personal Account Manager

Scott McGregor is a hands on Personal Account Manager at Nicol Insurance. Scott is all about building solid client relationships and finding the perfect insurance…

Diane Bailey

Personal Account Executive

For over three decades Diane Bailey has been a key player in the insurance industry, and she’s loved every minute of it. Working out of…

Shelley Colley

Personal Account Executive

Starting as a summer student more than three decades ago, Shelley Colley began her career in the insurance business and has never looked back. She…

Rebecca Simpson

Personal Account Manager

If you need someone to guide you through your personal insurance coverage, you can’t do better than Becca Simpson. She’s been our Personal Lines Account…

Denyse Faulkner

Personal Account Executive

For over fifteen years Denyse Faulkner has enjoyed being part of the Nicol Insurance personal lines team. Starting out as the front desk receptionist, she…

Melissa Western

Personal Account Manager

Melissa Western has nearly a decade of experience in personal financial planning. As an experienced Account Manager, she brings a wealth of knowledge in many aspects…

Brenda Vantyghem

Personal Account Manager

Brenda Vantyghem is a Personal Account Manager at Nicol Insurance’s Port Elgin Office. With years of customer service experience, Brenda establishes strong relationships with those…

Ashley Bailie

Personal Account Manager

Ashley Bailie is by nature passionate, as she’s eager to help people and make sure their needs are taken care of. The best part about…

Alyssa Beattie

Personal Account Manager

Alyssa Beattie has been “enjoying” the insurance business for nearly two decades. She joined the Nicol Insurance Kincardine office soon after completing her post-secondary education…

Maryheather Coelho

Personal Account Executive

Maryheather Coelho brings her expertise as a Law Clerk and over two decades of customer service experience to her role as a Personal Account Executive…

Pamela Davis

Retired

After more than 40 years in the insurance business, Pam Davis still enjoys what she does tremendously. She is however curious to know, “where did…

Keneisha Johnson

Personal Account Manager

Account Manager Keneisha Johnson works out of the Orangeville insurance office and is the main contact for day-to-day policy changes and billing inquires. Her coworkers…

Krista Lembo

Personal Account Executive

Krista is an enthusiastic member of the Nicol Insurance Orangeville office. She possesses a drive to learn new things and works hard to understand her…

Keira Overbeek

Personal Account Manager

Keira Overbeek enjoys working in her hometown of Orangeville, Ontario. Born and raised there, Keira enjoys her position as Personal Lines Account Manager with Nicol…

Kereel Mohammed

Personal Account Manager

Account Manager Kereel Mohammed brings a diverse skill set and a passion for customer service to Nicol Insurance. With a background in creative photography and…

Ana Mendonca

Personal Account Executive

With over 30 years experience in the insurance industry, Ana’s positive attitude and zeal for life make dealing with Ana a wonderful and easy experience.…

Jim Washington

Personal Account Executive

Jim Washington was the owner and lead broker at Landry Washington Insurance until its sale to Nicol Insurance in 2019. Jim now shares his lead…

Caitlyn Jacques

Personal Account Manager

Personal Lines Manager Caitlyn Jacques is dedicated to providing exemplary service with an emphasis on communication, and relationship building.

Crystal Machan

Personal Account Executive

Crystal Machan takes great satisfaction in her role as a Personal Account Executive for Nicol’s Woodstock Insurance location. She finds joy in assisting and collaborating…

Katie Stewart

Personal Account Manager

Katie Stewart brings a fresh perspective and enthusiasm to the Nicol team. As a Personal Lines Account Manager, Katie is armed with a Business Diploma,…

Harminder Singh Saggi

Personal Account Manager

Harminder Singh Saggi is a Personal Lines Account Manager at Nicol Insurance, working out of their Woodstock location. With a college certification in Insurance and…

Dan Fry

Personal Account Executive

As an Account Executive for Nicol Insurance, Dan Fry focuses on personal lines of the industry and is delighted to serve his community of Woodstock.…

Our Brokers, Our Family

Administration

Commercial Lines

Personal Lines

Owen Sound

Port Elgin

Kincardine

Bruce Peninsula

Orangeville

Mississauga

Woodstock